Getting a research manuscript published is a significant achievement, but rejection is an inevitable part of the process for most researchers. Understanding the most common reasons for rejection can help authors refine their work and improve their chances of acceptance.
This article explores the top 10 reasons manuscripts get rejected and provides actionable solutions to overcome them.
1. The Research Problem Is Not New or Significant
Why It Happens:
Journals prioritize research that contributes new knowledge or addresses critical gaps in the field. If your study lacks novelty or practical relevance, it may not be considered for publication.
How to Overcome It:
Conduct a thorough literature review to identify gaps in existing research.
Frame your research problem in a way that highlights its significance and potential impact.
Clearly state the novelty of your study in the introduction and discussion sections.
Consider interdisciplinary approaches to add a fresh perspective.
2. Methodological Issues and Flaws
Why It Happens:
Weak or flawed research methodologies undermine the credibility of findings, leading to rejection.
How to Overcome It:
Justify your methodological choices with references to established studies.
Clearly describe your study design, data collection, and analysis methods.
Use appropriate sample sizes and statistical tests.
Ensure reproducibility by providing sufficient methodological details.
Conduct pilot studies where applicable to validate methods.
3. Ethical Violations (Plagiarism, Data Manipulation, etc.)
Why It Happens:
Ethical breaches such as plagiarism, duplicate submissions, or manipulated data lead to immediate rejection and may damage an author’s reputation.
How to Overcome It:
Use plagiarism-checking tools like Turnitin or iThenticate before submission.
Always give proper credit through citations and references.
Follow institutional and journal ethical guidelines for human and animal research.
Be transparent about conflicts of interest and data sources.
4. Weak or Unsubstantiated Conclusions
Why It Happens:
Manuscripts with conclusions that are not fully supported by the data are often considered weak and unreliable.
How to Overcome It:
Ensure your conclusions align with the presented evidence.
Avoid overgeneralization or speculation beyond what your data supports.
Use tables, figures, and statistical tests to back up key claims.
Discuss alternative interpretations and limitations transparently.
5. Lack of Engagement with Recent Literature
Why It Happens:
Failing to reference recent studies makes a manuscript appear outdated or disconnected from current discourse.
How to Overcome It:
Regularly update your literature review to include the latest studies.
Cite key papers from high-impact journals in your field.
Compare your findings with recent research and explain how your study adds value.
6. Poor Positioning of the Study’s Novelty
Why It Happens:
Even if a study is novel, failing to clearly differentiate it from existing research can make it seem redundant.
How to Overcome It:
Explicitly state what is new about your study in the introduction.
Compare your work with previous research in the discussion section.
Clearly articulate the theoretical or practical advancements your study provides.
7. Poor Manuscript Presentation and Formatting
Why It Happens:
Journals receive hundreds of submissions, and poorly written or formatted manuscripts create a negative first impression.
How to Overcome It:
Follow the journal’s submission guidelines meticulously (e.g., referencing style, word count, structure).
Use clear, concise, and precise language.
Seek feedback from colleagues or professional editors.
Use grammar and readability tools like Grammarly or Hemingway Editor.
Ensure figures and tables are properly labeled and referenced.
8. Submitting to the Wrong Journal
Why It Happens:
Even high-quality research gets rejected if it does not align with a journal’s scope, audience, or focus.
How to Overcome It:
Carefully read the journal’s aims and scope before submission.
Review previously published articles to see if your work fits.
Consider journal ranking, impact factor, and readership relevance.
Use tools like Journal Finder (Elsevier) or Jane (Journal/Author Name Estimator) to find suitable journals.
9. Insufficient or Incorrect Data
Why It Happens:
Weak datasets, small sample sizes, or incorrect data handling can reduce the reliability of findings.
How to Overcome It:
Ensure your sample size is adequate for statistical significance.
Cross-check data for errors and inconsistencies.
Provide raw data or supplementary materials if required.
Use robust statistical software and methodologies for analysis.
Include sensitivity analyses or robustness checks to strengthen validity.
10. Lack of Proper Citations and References
Why It Happens:
Poorly cited manuscripts can raise concerns about credibility, plagiarism, or lack of thorough research.
How to Overcome It:
Follow the citation style required by the journal (APA, MLA, Chicago, etc.).
Cite primary sources instead of relying on secondary citations.
Avoid excessive self-citation to prevent bias.
Use reference management tools like Zotero, EndNote, or Mendeley for consistency.
Additional Tips for Successful Publication
✔ Revise and Resubmit After Rejection: If rejected, carefully read reviewer comments, make necessary improvements, and consider resubmitting.
✔ Engage in Peer Review: Reviewing papers for journals improves your own writing and helps you understand what editors look for.
✔ Seek Mentorship and Collaboration: Working with experienced researchers can improve manuscript quality.
✔ Practice Writing Regularly: Strong writing skills take time to develop, so consistently work on improving your academic writing.
✔ Attend Writing Workshops and Webinars: Many journals and institutions offer free training to help researchers enhance their manuscript quality.
Final Thoughts
Rejection is a common experience in academic publishing, but it can be a stepping stone toward success if approached constructively. By avoiding these common pitfalls, refining research quality, and persistently improving writing skills, researchers can significantly increase their chances of acceptance.
What has been your biggest challenge in getting published? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below!
Discover more from RSYN FYI
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.